
There are numerous regulations and requirements that health care providers have to follow, and failure to meet those expectations can result in consequences, even criminal charges. An investigation for health care fraud can threaten the career you’ve worked hard for. Whether you are facing charges through the Kings County Criminal Court or the U.S. Court for the Eastern District of New York, a Brooklyn health care fraud lawyer can help defend you.
The team at The Vitaliano Law Firm has years of experience in complex criminal and health care defense cases. We know how much these accusations can affect your career, in addition to the serious penalties of a criminal case. Because of this, our firm works hard to protect your future, find weaknesses in the prosecution’s case, and advocate for your rights.
Michael Vitaliano has spent years supporting individuals facing serious accusations. He also has experience as a prosecutor, giving him unique insight into how these cases are constructed and charged.
Our firm believes in clear communication and detail-focused legal representation. We listen to your side of things, assess your records and billing materials, answer your questions, and plan your defense strategy.
In fiscal year 2025, the U.S. Sentencing Commission reported 340 cases of health care fraud. The New York State Department of Financial Services (DFS) received 41,686 reports of health care fraud in the state in 2024, which made up 80% of fraud reports.
The majority of the DFS’s fraud reports involved no-fault fraud, but did result in 42 arrests the same year. Even when health care fraud is not done intentionally, it may still lead to criminal consequences.
Under federal law, health care fraud occurs when someone intentionally and purposefully commits or tries to commit one of the following related to health care benefits and services:
Even if you didn’t know it was a criminal offense, or you did not intend to commit fraud, you can still be charged under federal law.
Under New York laws, health care fraud occurs when all of the following are true:
The state charges health care fraud more harshly if you received a significant amount from health care fraud.
Health care fraud investigations can be for a range of alleged offenses. No matter the accusations you face, it is important to carefully go over the accusations and the associated billing records and state and federal laws. Common accusations in health care fraud cases include:
A health care fraud defense lawyer is crucial if you are facing charges or an investigation in Brooklyn, as legal defense brings you the greatest chance of minimizing criminal penalties or avoiding criminal conviction for the offense. An attorney can help you work quickly to build a defense, protect your career, and assess your legal options.
These cases are complex, especially when you’re also dealing with a high-stress job. The right attorney can give you the support you deserve.
Under New York law, there are five degrees of health care fraud. Fifth-degree fraud is the basic definition of health care fraud and can be charged regardless of the value of illegal payments. It is charged as a class A misdemeanor.
If you commit one or multiple instances of health care fraud, and the value of money you get reaches a certain amount in total, you can face more serious penalties:
If health care fraud is charged federally, it can result in up to ten years in prison and a fine. This can be increased to up to 20 years if the health care fraud violation caused someone serious bodily injury. If the violation caused someone’s death, then the offense can result in a term of any amount of years or life imprisonment.
If a health care fraud case is charged in New York, potential penalties include:
Fines can also be higher, as the court may decide to assign a fine that is up to double the value of the amount stolen during the fraud offenses.
These are only some of the criminal penalties you could face. There may be other civil, criminal, or administrative penalties, like restitution to the victims of the offenses. There are also criminal collateral consequences, like the loss of a professional license when you have a criminal record.
Healthcare fraud involves many different kinds of fraud, like improper claims made with Medicaid and Medicare, identity theft of a medical provider, illegal prescriptions made for controlled substances, overcharging for services, unbundling services to charge services separately instead of together, and failure to follow advertising laws.
Health care fraud also includes violations of the Anti-Kickback Statute or self-referral violations. There are many state and federal potential health care violations, and they can result in civil or criminal penalties.
The evidence that is needed to prove healthcare fraud depends on your case, but can include transaction receipts, billing records, claims made by medical providers to an insurer, communication between medical providers and patients, medical records, and other information. When you hire a health care fraud lawyer, they can help review the evidence the prosecution has, assess the requirements for the specific offense you are charged with, and investigate to find what evidence you can use to defend yourself.
The punishment for health insurance fraud will depend on the kind of fraud, whether it was done intentionally or by mistake, the amount of money involved in the offense, and other factors.
If the offense was unintentional, there may be only administrative and civil penalties, but also potentially criminal penalties. Intentional fraud results in criminal charges, which can lead to fines, imprisonment, and restitution to those who suffered financially from the fraud. Criminal penalties differ based on the offense.
Yes, people go to jail for health insurance fraud, although not all types of health insurance fraud result in jail time. When the fraud is not purposeful, there are different licensing and financial penalties from civil and administrative sources, but also criminal penalties in some cases. Purposeful fraud leads to criminal charges, and criminal conviction can lead to jail or prison time, depending on the severity of the offense.
At The Vitaliano Law Firm, we can help you protect your health care career and work against federal or state charges for health care fraud.
We can help you conduct an audit of your financial information and assess whether lack of intent will be an effective defense against your specific charges. We can also assess New York’s affirmative defense for bookkeepers and other individuals who are directed to take financial actions.
Get in contact with our experienced team today and see how we can safeguard your rights against fraud investigations.
